Guide · Diamond guides

The Four Cs: How to Choose a Diamond

Cut, colour, clarity and carat weight explained for buyers, with what changes when the diamond is an antique old cut.

By the Mozeris specialistsUpdated 7 min read

Diamond solitaire ring in platinum, 1.60 ct round brilliant
A 1.60 ct round brilliant cut diamond solitaire in platinum, from our stock.

The short answer

The Four Cs are cut, colour, clarity and carat weight, the grading system set out by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). Cut decides how much a diamond sparkles, colour runs from D (colourless) to Z, clarity measures inclusions from Flawless to Included, and carat is weight, not size: one carat is 0.2 grams.

  • Cut: proportions, symmetry and polish; it governs brilliance.
  • Colour: D to Z for white diamonds, plus fancy colours.
  • Clarity: FL, IF, VVS, VS, SI and I.

What are the Four Cs?

The Four Cs are cut, colour, clarity and carat weight. The system was set out by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) in the 1950s so that any diamond could be described in the same terms anywhere in the world. Laboratories such as GIA, IGI and HRD grade each C and record the results on a report.

No single C makes a diamond beautiful. A well-cut diamond of slightly lower colour often looks livelier than a poorly cut stone of higher colour, so the Cs are best weighed together, with the diamond in front of you.

Cut: the C that decides the sparkle

Cut means how well a diamond's facets are proportioned, aligned and polished, which decides how much light it returns as brilliance (white light), fire (flashes of colour) and scintillation (sparkle as it moves). GIA grades the cut of round brilliants from Excellent to Poor. Shape is a separate matter: round, oval, cushion, emerald, pear and marquise are shapes.

Antique cuts

Before modern cutting machines and the round brilliant, diamonds were cut by hand to keep as much weight as possible from the rough. The old mine cut, made from the eighteenth century to about 1900, is cushion shaped with a high crown, a small table and a large open culet. The old European cut, from about 1880 to the 1930s, is round with the same deep crown and open culet. The rose cut has a flat base and a domed top of triangular facets. These cuts give broader, softer flashes than a modern brilliant, and no laboratory gives them a cut grade.

Read more in our guide to old mine cut diamonds.

Old cut diamond rings in stock

Shop all 20

Colour: from D to Z, and fancy colours

White diamonds are graded on a scale from D, completely colourless, to Z, light yellow or brown. D to F is colourless, G to J near colourless, and K and below show a faint warm tint. Differences of one grade are very hard to see once a diamond is set, and a yellow gold setting makes a warmer stone look whiter.

Many antique old cut diamonds sit in the near colourless to faint range, and their warmth suits the candlelit settings they were cut for. Diamonds with strong, even colour, such as yellow, pink or blue, are graded on a separate fancy colour scale.

Clarity: inclusions and blemishes

Clarity measures the tiny natural features inside a diamond (inclusions) and on its surface (blemishes), seen under 10x magnification. GIA's scale runs:

GradeMeaning
FL / IFFlawless / internally flawless
VVS1, VVS2Very, very slightly included
VS1, VS2Very slightly included
SI1, SI2Slightly included
I1, I2, I3Included, often visible to the eye

Most VS and many SI diamonds look clean to the naked eye. Step cuts such as emerald and Asscher cuts show inclusions more clearly than brilliants, so clarity matters more for them.

Carat weight: weight, not size

A carat is a unit of weight: 0.2 grams, divided into 100 points, so 0.50 ct is 50 points. How big a diamond looks depends on its cut as well as its weight; a deep antique cut carries more weight below the girdle and can face up smaller than a modern brilliant of the same weight.

Weight (round brilliant)Approx. diameter
0.50 ct5.2 mm
1.00 ct6.5 mm
2.00 ct8.2 mm
3.00 ct9.4 mm
5.00 ct11 mm

Do not confuse diamond carats with gold carats: a 9 carat ring in the UK usually means 9KT gold, not a 9 ct diamond.

Diamond engagement rings in stock

Shop all 124

Certificates and our descriptions

A grading report from a laboratory such as GIA, IGI or HRD records the Four Cs, the measurements and any treatment. Where a diamond in our stock has a report, the listing names the laboratory and the report number. Most antique diamonds were set long before laboratory grading existed and have never been removed from their mounts; for those, our listings give careful estimates of weight, colour and clarity made in the setting.

Choosing a diamond: putting the Cs together

  1. Start with the shape and the setting you love: a round brilliant solitaire, an old cut cluster, an emerald cut Art Deco ring.
  2. Put cut first. A lively, well-proportioned stone flatters the other Cs.
  3. Look for eye-clean clarity rather than the highest grade on paper.
  4. Match colour to the metal: near colourless stones look white in yellow gold; platinum and white gold show colour more.
  5. Balance carat against the rest. A slightly smaller, brighter diamond often looks better than a larger, duller one.

You are welcome to view any ring by appointment in Mayfair or Braintree, or ask us for more photographs and a video.

Sources

Questions

What are the 4Cs of a diamond?

Cut, colour, clarity and carat weight: the grading system set out by the Gemological Institute of America. Cut governs brilliance, colour runs from D (colourless) to Z, clarity measures inclusions from Flawless to Included, and carat is weight.

Which of the Four Cs is most important?

Cut, because it decides how much light a diamond returns. A well-cut stone of lower colour or clarity often looks better than a poorly cut stone with higher grades.

How big is a 2, 3 or 5 carat diamond?

For well-cut round brilliants, a 0.50 ct diamond is about 5.2 mm across, 1 ct about 6.5 mm, 2 ct about 8.2 mm, 3 ct about 9.4 mm and 5 ct about 11 mm. Size grows more slowly than weight, so a 2 ct stone is not twice as wide as a 1 ct.

What does total carat weight mean on diamond earrings?

Total carat weight, written ct tw, is the combined weight of all the diamonds in a piece. A pair of 1 ct tw earrings has two stones of about 0.50 ct each. Always check whether a weight is for one stone or for the whole piece.

What are small diamonds such as 0.02 ct called?

Very small diamonds are described in points: 0.02 ct is 2 points and 0.10 ct is 10 points. Diamonds under about 0.20 ct are often called melee and are used in pavé, halos, eternity rings and the shoulders of rings. In antique jewellery, tiny rose cut and single cut diamonds fill the same role.

Is a 9 carat diamond ring a diamond of 9 carats?

Usually not, in the UK. A 9 carat ring normally means the gold is 9KT, 37.5% pure, hallmarked 375, set with diamonds of any weight. Gold carats measure purity out of 24; diamond carats measure weight.

Why are most diamond rings 18KT gold?

18KT gold, 75% pure and hallmarked 750, is hard enough to hold claws securely while keeping a rich colour, so it is the usual standard for fine diamond rings. 22KT gold is softer, so claws bend and wear faster. Platinum is also common.

What diamond clarity is best?

Flawless is the top of GIA's clarity scale, followed by IF, VVS, VS, SI and I. Flawless stones are very rare. Most VS and many SI diamonds look clean to the naked eye, so they are a common choice.

Should a diamond have fluorescence?

Fluorescence is a glow, usually blue, that some diamonds show under ultraviolet light; GIA reports that about a quarter to a third of diamonds fluoresce. Faint or medium fluorescence rarely affects how a diamond looks in daylight. Very strong blue fluorescence can make a few stones look slightly hazy, so check the stone itself.

What is an emerald cut diamond?

An emerald cut is a rectangular step cut with cut corners and long, parallel facets that give broad flashes of light rather than the sparkle of a brilliant. Its open table shows inclusions and colour clearly. It was popular in Art Deco jewellery.

Do antique diamonds have certificates?

Most do not, because they were cut and set long before laboratory grading existed. Where an antique diamond has been graded, the listing names the laboratory; otherwise weight, colour and clarity are careful estimates made in the setting.

What makes a pink diamond pink?

Most pink diamonds owe their colour to distortion in the crystal lattice formed under pressure deep in the earth, not to an impurity. Natural pink diamonds are graded on GIA's fancy colour scale.

Why are most diamond rings 18KT gold, and can they be 22KT?

18KT gold, 75% pure and hallmarked 750, is hard enough to hold claws securely while keeping a rich colour, so it is the usual standard for fine diamond rings. 22KT gold, 91.6% pure, is softer, so claws bend and wear faster, though it is used for diamond jewellery in some countries. Platinum is also common.

What is the largest diamond ever found?

The Cullinan, found in South Africa in 1905, is the largest gem diamond ever found, at 3,106 ct rough. It was cut into nine major stones, including the Cullinan I of 530.2 ct, set in the British Sceptre with the Cross, and the Cullinan II in the Imperial State Crown. Diamonds of 200 ct or more are extremely rare.