Return to Tiffany: Value Guide
The heart tag that began as a key-ring slogan and became one of Tiffany's most recognised lines. In silver and in gold, here's what yours is worth and how to sell it in the UK.
What Is Your Return to Tiffany Worth?
Send a photo — including the engraving and any box or pouch — for a free, no-obligation valuation. We reply within one working day.
The line began in 1969 with a simple idea: a key ring stamped "Please Return to Tiffany & Co., New York" so a lost key could find its way home. The slogan caught on, and Tiffany turned the round and heart-shaped tags into a full jewellery collection that has stayed in demand ever since.
What is Return to Tiffany jewellery?
The signature is the tag charm — a round disc or a flat heart — engraved "Please Return to Tiffany & Co., New York 925", across bracelets, pendants, necklaces, earrings, rings and key rings. Most pieces are sterling silver; some are 18ct gold or rose gold, and there are blue-enamel "Tiffany Blue" heart versions. Genuine pieces are signed Tiffany & Co. and marked 925 or 750, with crisp, even engraving.
What drives the value
Metal
Sterling silver is the entry tier; 18ct gold and rose-gold pieces sit well above it.
Piece & size
Bracelets and larger tags above small charms and single earrings.
Box & pouch
Original Tiffany blue box and pouch add value and reassure on authenticity.
Condition
Bright metal, crisp engraving, sound clasp, no heavy scratching or tarnish.
What is Return to Tiffany jewellery worth in the UK?
Resale depends on metal, piece and completeness — indicative bands:
Indicative only — your piece depends on metal, weight, condition and papers. Send a photo for a free, accurate valuation.
Selling Your Tiffany
What we look at when buying Return to Tiffany:
- Authenticity — Tiffany & Co. signature, 925 / 750 mark.
- Metal — Silver vs 18ct gold or rose gold.
- Engraving — Crisp, even slogan lettering.
- Piece — Bracelet, pendant, earrings, ring.
- Completeness — Blue box and pouch.
We buy Tiffany directly — fair prices, immediate payment, no auction fees.
How to sell Tiffany jewellery in the UK
Send clear photos of the piece, the Tiffany & Co. signature and metal mark, and any box or pouch. We confirm authenticity, weigh the metal, and give an honest figure with immediate payment — no auction commission. More on our sell your Tiffany jewellery page, our Tiffany T guide and whether designer jewellery holds its value.
Tiffany in stock
Value Your Tiffany Jewellery
Send photographs of the piece, the signature and any papers — we'll give you an honest, no-obligation valuation.
⚠️ Strictly by appointment only — no walk-ins at either showroom.
Frequently Asked Questions
Return to Tiffany jewellery — common questions.
Does Return to Tiffany hold its value?
The silver pieces are recognisable and resaleable but sit closer to material value; the 18ct gold and diamond versions hold value far better. Box and pouch help.
Is mine silver or gold?
Most pieces are sterling silver, marked 925. Gold versions are marked 750 (18ct). The mark and weight decide the tier — send a photo and we'll confirm.
How much is mine worth?
It depends on the metal, the piece and size, condition and papers. Send a photo for a free, accurate valuation.
How do I know mine is genuine?
Genuine pieces are signed Tiffany & Co., marked 925 or 750, with crisp, even engraving. Send photos of the engraving and marks and we'll confirm.
Do you buy silver Tiffany?
Yes — though silver pieces are lower value than the gold and diamond fine jewellery.
Can you value it on WhatsApp?
Yes. Message +44 7494 214652 with photos of the piece and engraving and we'll reply, usually within a working day.
Send Us Your Photographs
Attach photos of the piece and the Tiffany & Co. engraving. We'll respond within one working day.